When business partners fall into disagreement, the resulting disputes are often personal, complex, and legally demanding. For members of the Jewish community, these challenges are compounded by the need to navigate two distinct legal systems: Halacha (Torah) and secular law. At 59Law.com, based in Monsey, New York, we offer a rare and essential service: comprehensive legal representation grounded in both American civil law and Jewish law. Whether a case proceeds in a Beis Din or in civil court, (or both) we are uniquely qualified to guide clients through every stage of their partnership disputes, without the need to retain both a to’en (rabbinical advocate) and a secular attorney. We also ensure you are in the proper Bes Din to maximize your chances of attaining true and enforceable justice. When a Bes Din arbitration culminates with a P’sak or award, we then take that award and confirm it with the courts as a final arbitration award thereby allowing the client to fully enforce their rights within the US legal system.
Business partnerships are founded on trust, mutual interest, and clearly defined obligations. When that trust breaks down, the legal mechanisms for resolution differ significantly between Halacha and the civil legal system.
Under Halacha, the foundation for partnership law is deeply rooted in sources such as Choshen Mishpat, particularly Simanim 176–182, which discuss partnership formation (shutfim), obligations, fiduciary duties, and dissolution. For instance, sometimes Halacha can establishes that a verbal agreement between partners, accompanied by a custom of industry specific course of dealings can be binding under Jewish law—even in the absence of a formal written contract. Contrast this with civil law, where written agreements are heavily emphasized and generally required for enforcement in court. Of course, each situation revolves against its own unique dynamic.
A common misconception is that Beis Din lacks the authority to issue enforceable rulings. Nothing could be further from the truth- in reality, a properly structured arbitration agreement allows Beis Din rulings to carry significant legal weight under New York law, so long as both parties agree in advance. In fact, rarely will the courts even reverse a P’sak (Arbitration award) and therefore, quite the contrary, the courts strongly and routinely enforce Arbitration awards. At 59Law.com, we ensure that such agreements are drafted in accordance with both Halacha and New York State or other State law, preserving the sanctity of the Beis Din process while protecting your enforceable rights in secular terms. We routinely handle cases involving the following:
In Beis Din, the process follows halachic protocol, including hazmanah (formal summons), to’en and nit’an roles (plaintiff and defendant advocates), and reliance on Dayanim (judges) trained in rabbinic jurisprudence. As both licensed attorneys and trained rabbinic advocates, we bridge the procedural and cultural gaps to ensure our clients’ voices are heard—clearly, competently, and respectfully in both venues. We also have a team of Rabbinic Advisors who regularly advise us further to ensure exhaustive Torah compliance.
Knowing your rights as a business partner begins with understanding your obligations. Both civil law and Halacha impose fiduciary responsibilities on partners, but the details differ.
In Jewish law, a partner is considered a shomer (custodian) depending on the specific terms of the agreement. According to Rambam, Hilchos Shutfim 4:1, each partner is responsible for the other’s share in certain losses, unless otherwise agreed. This responsibility affects not only how profits are divided, but also how losses and liabilities are borne.
Under New York law, partners owe each other duties of loyalty and care. Failure to disclose material information or engaging in self-dealing can result in legal liability, and in some cases, personal financial exposure. In the absence of a written agreement, the New York Partnership Law governs by default, often with results that may contradict halachic expectations.
An observant client may feel torn: Should they go to civil court and risk violating the halachic and very severe prohibition of arkaos (litigating before non-Jewish courts which can be a Chilul Hashem), or should they limit themselves to Beis Din and risk enforceability? With 59Law.com, we strive to implement strict Torah compliance while at the same time ensuring that compliance is accomplished in the most prudent way possible. We prepare every case with dual objectives in mind: compliance with din Torah and protection of your civil rights.
We also address procedural pitfalls. For instance, civil courts may not recognize certain verbal or handshake agreements that Halacha would deem binding. Without the right guidance, a well-intentioned frum businessman can inadvertently forfeit legal protections by failing to document obligations in a manner that holds up in both systems.
Our firm ensures that your interests are not only articulated in a way that resonates with Dayanim, but also protected through civil instruments like arbitration clauses, partnership agreements, and settlement terms that withstand judicial scrutiny and pave the way for full civil enforcement.
If you’re facing a business partnership dispute and want representation that honors both your halachic obligations and your legal rights, contact 59Law.com today. We’ll guide you through the process, from hazmanah to judgment enforcement, helping you achieve a resolution that is fair, binding, and aligned with your values.
© 2025 59Law.com. All rights reserved.
